“WOAH!” is what you’ll shriek when legit birthday cake batter oozes into your mouth after biting into the Cake Batter cupcake. How do they bake a cupcake and keep batter filling in the middle in liquid form? There are all sorts of surprises inside Molly’s cupcakes such as cookie dough, and these treats are unlike any other cupcake you will find in New York. The actual cake is better than the icing. In addition, you can build-your-own cupcake on the spot choosing from: cake flavors, icing and toppings. The available board games and swing-style seating keeps this a friendly hang out. Just when you thought you were over the cupcake trend, Molly’s Cupcakes jumps in and offers some of the prettiest, unique and irresistible options to stuff your face with.
However, do not overlook the other treats. This place will score you the best peanut butter cookie in the city. Moist, chewy and soft.